Banner website_back to school

Denise Bombardier: “In America, Mr. Matzneff Would Already Be in Jail”

In 1990, the Quebecer journalist was the only person to condemn the acts of pedophilia committed by Gabriel Matzneff. The successful French writer was an idol of the Parisian intelligentsia who used his attraction to young boys and girls as a major inspiration for his books.

After being insulted by her French colleagues, Denise Bombardier has become a heroine for victims who have come forward. Author Vanessa Springora thanked her in her book, Consent, published in France in January, in which she recounts how she was manipulated by the writer, 30 years her senior, when she was just 14. “She was so damaged,” said Bombardier in an interview with France-Amérique. “I had to say something. It was too serious.”


France-Amérique: On March 2, 1990, you confronted Gabriel Matzneff on the television show Apostrophes. What happened afterwards?

Denise Bombardier: I received hundreds of letters from people in France thanking me, but the national newspaper Le Monde never published another article about my books. I was boycotted. My novel had been nominated for the Prix Femina, and after that I was never put forward for another literary award. People said I needed to get laid. Others said I was a bad writer — the ultimate insult for ruining a literary reputation in France. I was punished for denouncing a pervert and the incestuous world that protected him. “This is going to harm your book,” said my publisher at Seuil. “You’re going to be lynched. Your future as a writer in France will be compromised.”

The French president, François Mitterrand himself, summoned you to the Elysée Palace…

He did, a few days after I appeared on television. I told him that in my country, Mr. Matzneff would already be in jail. “You know these Parisian intellectuals as well as I do,” he replied, brushing it aside. “They’re so obsessed with appearing to be liberal, especially about these delicate subjects, that they make mistakes.”

Is this immunity enjoyed by writers typically French, or could the same sort of scandal happen in North America?

Literature is sacred in France. Writers are invited to the Elysée Palace, taken out for lunch, and awarded medals. They dominate the country’s intellectual, cultural, and political life. They have formed another monarchy; the monarchy of letters. This status cannot be compared to that of writers in North America. In the United States, the world of cinema is legendary. The Weinstein affair is a case in point.

Did the #MeToo movement provoke the Matzneff affair?

No, #MeToo is a North American phenomenon. Relationships between men and women are not the same in France, and some French women have come forward to defend the “right to seduction.” The Matzneff affair was sparked by the publication of Vanessa Springora’s testimony. Now no one can believe that he invented his relationships with children. This is no longer a literary debate.

What does the future hold for writers in France?

They’re being brought down to earth with a bang! Their status is changing: Writers are no longer sacred figures; they can no longer commit crimes and use literature as a shield. We are witnessing a cultural revolution in France. The mentality of younger generations is also different. The journalists who have interviewed me for the last three weeks are men and women between the ages of 30 and 40. They are shocked by Matzneff’s actions and the silence of the authorities. This is the future.

  • Perhaps Mr. Matzneff cannot face execution on the guillotine, but maybe a little guillotine can be built to remove his offending male member and prevent future children from being victimized by this pervert.

  • Oui… Enfin, aux USA n’importe qui peut aller en prison : dans certains Etats, une personne de 19 ans qui sort avec une autre de 16 ou 17 peut être arrêtée par la police et jetée en prison sans aucun motif valable. Le vrai scandale est là. Et inversement Mickael Jackson, pédophile notoire, n’a jamais été inquiété par la justice. Donc les chanteurs à succès ont le droit de commettre des crimes sans que personne ne s’en inquiète, tandis que des citoyens lambda innocents sont incarcérés. Cette polémique est donc doublement artificielle et a pour unique effet d’alimenter la démagogie médiatique habituelle en taisant la sordide réalité.

  • Voilà bien une tache sur la carrière de Bernard Pivot. Premièrement, il n’aurait pas du l’inviter et deuxièmement, il aurait dû applaudir aux dénonciations de Denise Bombardier.

  • Le terme “révolution culturelle” renvoie directement à Mao et aux persécutions des artistes et des intellectuels. Très significatif. On ne combat pas les excès des uns avec l’extrémisme des autres.

  • J’étais devant Apostrophes en 90, effarée de ce qui se jouait : applaudissant Denise, écoeurée par l’effronté et éhonté Matzneff, désolée de voir Pivot embarqué et embarrassé ! Néanmoins, c’est très très bien que la parole des femmes se libère et que les hommes qui s’arrogent un pouvoir illimité (!) se voient rappeler les cadres du respect, de la dignité humaine, de la conscience humaine et de la maîtrise des pulsions… Nous ne sommes pas des bêtes !!!

  • Wow I am impressed by Denise Bombardier for denouncing a pervert notwithstanding being scolded by the phony French intelligentsia and being blackballed by French literary society. It takes courage to be the only one in the room calling out the obvious that no one wants to recognize.

  • Denise Bombardier had the courage to tell Gabriel Matzneff that his behaviour was criminal and that he was hiding his sickness behind the screen of the art of litterature. Mr. Matzneff’s agressive reaction to Mrs. Bombardier’s comments is a clear proof that he feels guilty.

  • Denouncing the sins of the famous is, let us hope, a passing fad. A sane society needs role models to emulate, not a series of sadly flawed villains who nonetheless made valuable contributions to society — e.g., Harvey Weinstein, Roman Polansky, etc. Shall we start removing from art museums the work of all artists who failed to live up to our current moral standards?

  • Related

    • Roman Polanski rattrapé par #MeTooRoman Polanski rattrapé par #MeToo La France aura mis plus de temps que l'Amérique du Nord à s’attaquer aux délits sexuels de ses artistes. Cinéaste vénéré en France mais boycotté et poursuivi par la justice aux Etats-Unis […] Posted in Opinion
    • Le talent n’excuse plus les crimesLe talent n’excuse plus les crimes Le monde culturel français est ébranlé par les frasques sexuelles du cinéaste Roman Polanski et par la pédophilie avouée de l'écrivain Gabriel Matzneff. Ils considéraient que leur talent […] Posted in Opinion